Sigma SW9C

Question
Hi Sid, I抦 interested in buying a used Smith & Wesson Sigma SW9C. However, I抳e read some comments in internet forums that the older model sigmas had problems like failure to fire, feeding, extracting and ejecting problems, a bad trigger, poor accuracy, broken parts, etc. Is this true? Are the older sigmas unreliable? What problems did they have? Is this the reason why Smith & Wesson doesn抰 make the older models anymore? Is this gun ideal for self-defense?

Answer
Hi Gary,

A complex series of questions, many of which the answer/s to are subjective. That said, lets give it a try.

There have been a lot of emotions connected to the S&W company and products over the years for a variety of reasons that I won't attmept to respond to here. Point being, keep this in mind as you solicit opinions concerning same.

The Sigma was introduced in 1994 in the Sigma 40 version followed by the 9mm. It was basically a "knock off" of the Glock and intended to be Smith's answer to same. In fact Glock eventually filed a lawsuit against S&W for patent infringement.

Smith ended up changing the trigger system to avoid patent issues with Glock. The original versions did develop a reputation for a stiff trigger and some feeding/ejection problems.

Smith changed the original design in 1999 by shortening the barrel and slide, adding an accessory rail, and more importantly, enlarging the ejection port.

Is the Sigma 9 a "ideal gun for self defense" ? Well, that depends on who you ask. I certainly cannot rule it out. If it is what you can afford and in good condition, you would be better off with this pistol than many others on the used market. However, there are also many "better" selections available.

A "ideal self defence gun" is another whole topic in itself. However, I would personally prefer a larger caliber (IE. something in a 40) than a 9mm. I would check out the used market at your local F.F.L. dealer and/or on the net (IE. Gunbroker.com) and see what else is available in the same price range. I think you can do better than the Sigma unless you are buying it dirt cheap.

I know that you have not ask the question, but why not consider a good used revolver in a 38/357 or larger caliber? The market is flooded with them and most can be obtained at very resonable prices. Just a thought for you to consider.

I hope this information helps you out in your selection process. Good luck and have fun !

Sid Lark