Home Outdoor Sports FAQS Fishing Golf swimming Skiing and Skating Cycling Climbing Other Outdoor Sports Camping

blocking the basepath

2016/7/15 17:06:06


Question
this pertains to the question previously answered july 30 ie Runner on 1st and 3rd with 1 out.  Batter hits a ground ball to the third baseman - runner on third runs home on contact.  Third baseman throws home and catcher is blocking the plate, the runner beats the throw (does not slide, but avoids contact with the catcher).  Runner's momentum takes him over the catcher and the umpire signals "safe" - then the catcher tags runner and umpire calls him out.  Umpire stated that a call had to be made when runner past home plate and stated that the runner did not touch home plate.  Should the umpire have made any signal?  The runner never made an attempt to go back to touch base because of the umpire's original call.
i thought that the play would end with an obstruction call on the catcher and the runner would be safe regardless.

Answer
Hi sbalser,

I briefly considered that but I wasn't there and the OP made no mention that there may have been obstruction and most players recognize what it is.  The PU didn't call it either. If we have obstruction we don't use a "safe" call but rather "dead ball" which didn't happen here.

My sense of his question was the "safe" then "out".  I just gave them the proper mechanic which the umpire seemed to have.  

Mark
  1. Prev:
  2. Next:
Related Articles
bat in the way
Obstruction, or not, while trying to pick-up a ball
interferance
thrown ball hits bat left on field by batter
hey i have a ? about something that idk wat 2 do... Can u help?
Double Base
Girls fast pitch leaving base too soon.
Batted ball hit runner on base.
third stike...not dropped
More Great Links

Shorthanded player rule

QuestionTeam starts shorthanded. two players show up top 2nd, when can they enter game?? Answe

softball Earned Run vs Run

QuestionWhat is the difference between an Earned Run and just a run scored? If a player is wal

A Team vs. B Team

QuestionI am very new to fastpitch tournament and travel teams. My daughter just started playin

Contact management E-mail : [email protected]

Copyright © 2005-2016 Outdoor sports All Rights Reserved