ASA 10U obstruction and collisions

Question
Mark,

Thanks for the quick answer.

I'd like to explore further, hypothetical.
SS was indeed not fielding the ball, nor in possession of the ball.
How would you deal with the SS remaining in line btwn 2nd and 3rd until runner from 2nd swerves, behind SS, apparently to avoid a collision. Now at the same time SS hops toward pitcher, in apparent move to avoid collision. Can it be ruled obstruction based upon the runner having to alter their course to avoid collision?

thanks,
Bill

-------------------------

Followup To

Question -
Mark,

I just found this forum and have learned much.

My question involves obstruction and intentional collisions.

10U ASA girls fastpitch.
No overriding local rules regarding collisions, etc.

SS standing in basline between 2nd and 3rd, does not have the ball. Runner from 2nd base does not swerve to avoid collision, nor does SS move to avoid collision and give the runner clear path to
3rd. Collision occurs, runner and SS go down, confusion sets in as to obstruction, intentional collision, etc.

I see this as obstruction happening the instant that SS hinders the runners path, i.e. before the collision. As it is impossible for the SS to evaporate at the instant before collision, as well as runner to swerve at the instant before collision.

The collision is a seperate and unfortunate incident that is not prohibited by any rule, since both SS and runner made no effort to avoid a collision.

Thus only infraction is defensive obstruction.

thanks,
Bill


Answer -
Hi Bill,

This has a very simple answer.....

A)  If F6 was attempting to field a batted ball we have interference, dead ball, and the runner out.  The runner in this case is responsible for the collision.

B)  If F6 was not in possession of the ball (as you say) or not attempting to field a batted ball, we have obstruction, delayed dead ball and will protect the runner to the base they would have made.  The fielder in this case is responsible for the collision.

Mark

Answer
Hi again Bill,

Absolutely, obstruction is the act of a fielder not in possession of the ball or not in the act of fielding a batted ball that impedes the progress of a runner legally running the bases.

If a runner alters their path because of a defensive player that meets the above requirements we have obstruction.

Mark